Judge had never been a HC at the college level, or any level it appears, before getting the Giants job (.303 winning % over two years as HC there). He got the job as a member of the New England Patriots coaching tree. He is the Giants let's hire an unprepared Asst Coach to be our HC philosophy that our "powers to be" at State have followed since at least Charlie Shira(16-45-2. 1967 through 1972), and then we promoted him to AD!