MSU big four vs. Ole Miss big four- who would you rather have?

[War Machine Dawg]

I'll take Clayborn, Treadwell, Jones, and Conner.

Clayborn: The next Gabe Jackson. Very, very good in a time share role his freshman season. No injury history, unlike Tunsil.

Treadwell: Legit, immediate impact WR. He's big and physical with enough speed to get downfield. Unlike most of the other BearShark prima donnas, he seems to stay out of trouble. Bear may be the better player in the long run, but Treadwell's a 3-and-done type player.

Jones: Since it's the night after WrestleMania, I'll say CJ is The Beast Incarnate. Dominant whether he's lined up inside at DT or outside at DE. Another 3-and-done type.

Conner: An elite talent who would solidify the safety position for us. Very, very fast and not afraid to hit. Big threat once he gets the ball in his hands. Like with Treadwell & CJ, 3-and-done level of talent.

I'm sorry, but anyone taking Bear or Shump over Treadwell or Conner is a homer. An argument can be made for Tunsil, but I went with Clayborn because Tunsil looks like he might be the BearSharks' Tobias Smith. Great player who can't stay healthy.

[NewTweederEndzoneDance]

Tunsil, Conner, Jones, Treadwell.

Problem for Ole Miss is that, other than kicker, those may be the only positions on their entire team that are better than our corresponding position.

This is pretty spot on. Anyone who would take Clayborne over Tunsil at this point of their careers is just giving the maroon koolaid a swig. He may well turn out better, but at the moment at least, Tunsil looks to be a top draft pick at one of the most important positions in the game. They also play different positions, so its not a clear cut comparison. Jones is much better than Knemdiche and Treadwell is more polished at the moment than Wilson. Conner and Shumpert are playing different positions unless I missed something, so I'm not sure how you can really compare them. Since we have so many good RBs, I suppose I'd prefer to have Conner though.

But after that, I'm with Shotgun. I'd take our guys for the most part. I'd probably also want Prewitt. Otherwise, I'd like their LB Bryant, CJ at rush end, maybe Vincent Sanders and that frosh TE they have to stretch the field from the TE spot - but those guys wouldn't necessarily be clear cut starters for us. They've got a couple OL that would either start for us or give us good depth as well (thinking that Golson kid that FSU is all pissed about from that class)

[jumbo]

Tunsil, Jones, Conner and Treadwell right now.

[mic]

Better comparison is the Miss Grand Slam Class of 2011... Looks like we won this battle

Dak....... Snoop
McKinnley....... CJ
Cox ....... Tobias
PJ....... Moncrief
P Smith....... Morris
Josh Robinson ....... Prewitt
Calhoun ...... Golson
Dee....... Denzel NK
Market....... Karmeon Wood
Malone....... Bryant


And I even left off the best QB to come out of Miss since Jason Campbell .. Miller..

[Coach34]

I chose Clayborn based off 2 things:

1. Watching Clayborn go H2H with Jones in practice and it was basically a draw. Clayborn is about to show what kind of player he is.

2. Watching Tunsil on the sideline during the Egg Bowl testing his knee and then saying he couldn't go. Tunsil could have played- he was moving fine. He didn't want back in. That's not a guy I want. He has great talent- but I question his heart when it gets tough

[BeardoMSU]

Tunsil - regardless of how injury prone he is or his attitude, that dude has elite talent, which is something we'd love to have on our O-line. His "attitude" issues may be different if he played for a different coach, too, which is something worth taking into account. Mullen doesn't pander that shit; if he acts like a bitch, he won't play, but I've seen Dan bring the best out of his players since day 1 (an exception being Quay, but that's no ones fault but his own).

Treadwell - again, elite talent. All the "bubble screen" stuff is funny, but if you think thats all he's gonna be catching this year, you're gonna have a rude awakening; he is gonna catch some big passes this year, and I wish we had him. As far as Bear: I'm a huge fan of his, and if was Bear vs. other WR's from the SEC, I'd probably take him. His potential is huge (not many 6'6" WR's out there), so I'm hoping he'll show some big flash this year where I'd feel comfortable taking him over Paidwell.

Jones - all week and twice on Sunday. The dude is a stud. That being said, if I had a second choice for a DL, I'd take RK. Those two guys on the same D-line would be disgusting. Though both are elite, I see Jones as being more of an outside threat and very versatile, where RK will likely be a career DT.

Shump and Conner? This is tough because they play different positions. If you ask me what I think we need more this year, it'd be a good safety. RB has become a fairly easy position to fill, especially for us; I can't remember the last time we didn't have a stable of good backs.

I agree, that outside of these few guys, OM doesn't have the position guys that we have.

[msstate7]

If I had to choose right now between bear and treadwell I'd probably choose treadwell. Down the stretch in the egg it was bear making plays though not treadwell. I think after this year this argument gets much, much closer

[bgdog]

Tunsil, Treadwell, Jones, Conner

[codeDawg]

I don't have time to do the comparison right now, but the other missing angle is depth. UM has some great talent from the big recruiting class, but he have quality depth at almost every position but OL and S right now. The vast majority of our players are 5-year guys. We have a lot of redshirted 4-stars, and it isn't because they didn't have the talent to play as freshmen.

[thf24]

My picks were based on what I think their performance will be in 2014- not anything else.

Slightly off topic, but based on your picks there, are you expecting Redmond to take over Love's starting spot at some point? Just curious.

[codeDawg]

Slightly off topic, but based on your picks there, are you expecting Redmond to take over Love's starting spot at some point? Just curious.

Not C34, but I would doubt he starts over Love because: 1. Mullen honors seniority, and 2. they will both play a lot so it won't matter who starts in the end.

[1bigdawg]

I think Shump chose wrong. Shump will be a solid to good SEC RB, but he could have been a great LB/SS on defense.

I agree on Shump, but I wonder if he has the foot speed and hips for SS.

[Coach34]

No- Love will start and play well. I put Redmond in there because I think he is better overall and makes our Nickel Package really tough. We'll play a shit ton of Nickel this year also because we are good enough upfront to play it on run downs vs certain teams.

[Pollodawg]

What about trying Shump at fullback?

[Coach34]

What about trying Shump at fullback?

He was in the Liberty Biwl in goal line. And that is the only time we run a FB

[smootness]

I'll admit, I only really know the stars from MSU. Chris Jones, McKinney and Lewis are obvious takes. They're ballers. Dillon Day is a great center with experience."

This is my favorite part of the post. 'I only know a few guys on State's team, and I know every player on Ole Miss' roster, so here is my team of the best players from the state.'

It would be like me saying:



'Here is my 'All-NL East' team:

C - Evan Gattis
1B - Freddie Freeman
2B - Dan Uggla, unless any other team employs a 2B
SS - Andrelton Simmons
3B - Chris Johson
RF - Bryce Harper
CF - Jason Heyward (I moved him)
LF - Justin Upton

SP - Julio Teheran
SP - Mike Minor
SP - Steven Strasburg
SP - Alex Wood
SP - Aaron Harang; or I don't know, does another team have a pitcher better?

*I'll admit, the only players in the division I know outside of the Braves are Bryce Harper and Steven Strasburg.'

[msstate7]

This is my favorite part of the post. 'I only know a few guys on State's team, and I know every player on Ole Miss' roster, so here is my team of the best players from the state.'

It would be like me saying:



'Here is my 'All-NL East' team:

C - Evan Gattis
1B - Freddie Freeman
2B - Dan Uggla, unless any other team employs a 2B
SS - Andrelton Simmons
3B - Chris Johson
RF - Bryce Harper
CF - Jason Heyward (I moved him)
LF - Justin Upton

SP - Julio Teheran
SP - Mike Minor
SP - Steven Strasburg
SP - Alex Wood
SP - Aaron Harang; or I don't know, does another team have a pitcher better?

*I'll admit, the only players in the division I know outside of the Braves are Bryce Harper and Steven Strasburg.'

Plug Santana in for strasburg and you nailed it***

[War Machine Dawg]

This is my favorite part of the post. 'I only know a few guys on State's team, and I know every player on Ole Miss' roster, so here is my team of the best players from the state.'

It would be like me saying:



'Here is my 'All-NL East' team:

C - Evan Gattis
1B - Freddie Freeman
2B - Dan Uggla, unless any other team employs a 2B
SS - Andrelton Simmons
3B - Chris Johson
RF - Bryce Harper
CF - Jason Heyward (I moved him)
LF - Justin Upton

SP - Julio Teheran
SP - Mike Minor
SP - Steven Strasburg
SP - Alex Wood
SP - Aaron Harang; or I don't know, does another team have a pitcher better?

*I'll admit, the only players in the division I know outside of the Braves are Bryce Harper and Steven Strasburg.'

Nice! Now for the REAL NL East team:

C: Jarrod Saltalamacchia/Evan Gattis (C is pretty much a platoon situation for teams now)
1B: Freddie Freeman
2B: Anthony Rendon
SS: Andrelton Simmons
3B: David Wright
LF: Bryce Harper
CF: Jason Heyward
RF: Jayson Werth

SP: Steven Strasburg
SP: Cole Hamels
SP: Julio Teheran
SP: Zack Wheeler
SP: Mike Minor

Closer: Craig Kimbrel

Note: If I can move IF players, I'm putting Ian Desmond as the starter at 2B. It sucks that having to choose between his bat and Simmons' D. Rendon has the most upside of the NL East 2B, though. All the others suck: Uggla, Daniel Murphy, Chase Utley, and Derek Dietrech.

[UMCDawg16]

Jones over Kimdashian but outside of him I would take the OM player over ours. Clayborn and DeRunnya have a chance to be special though.

[smootness]

Nice! Now for the REAL NL East team:

C: Jarrod Saltalamacchia/Evan Gattis (C is pretty much a platoon situation for teams now)
1B: Freddie Freeman
2B: Anthony Rendon
SS: Andrelton Simmons
3B: David Wright
LF: Bryce Harper
CF: Jason Heyward
RF: Jayson Werth

SP: Steven Strasburg
SP: Cole Hamels
SP: Julio Teheran
SP: Zack Wheeler
SP: Mike Minor

Closer: Craig Kimbrel

Note: If I can move IF players, I'm putting Ian Desmond as the starter at 2B. It sucks that having to choose between his bat and Simmons' D. Rendon has the most upside of the NL East 2B, though. All the others suck: Uggla, Daniel Murphy, Chase Utley, and Derek Dietrech.

I think this is pretty spot-on, though I might put Ruiz at catcher and might put Stanton in the OF.

And obviously Harvey moves into the rotation once he's back, and I'd move Wheeler out. Also, someone could take Strasburg's spot this year if he doesn't stay healthy.

But I'd go Simmons over Desmond without even thinking about it. I think he's more valuable than Desmond right now and clearly has more room to improve with his offense.