-

Originally Posted by
yjnkdawg
Any alum who wants MSU to lose to OM, for any reason, needs to evaluate their loyalty to our school. I don't think we will win, based upon the current circumstances, but I'm sure not going to hope we ever lose to OM, in any sport and for looking at the big picture or whatever reason. I also want a coaching change ASAP too.
How many loses overall is a win vs OM worth? Hypothetical: We can go 1-11 with a win over OM, OR 14-1 with a loss to OM, but we win the SEC and the national championships. Which do you pick? I'd argue anyone who picks 1-11 isn't a State fan at all, just an OM hater.
But, lets say it's 6-6 with a win over OM vs 7-5 with a loss to them. I'd probably pick the 6-6 myself because beating them is worth 2 wins, not 1.
Now let's ask this hypothetical: If Joe starts, what will our record be next year? What will it be in '21 with a new coach who has to dig out of the even bigger hole we'll be in after year 3 of Joe vs 2? Now, what would the record over the next 2 years be with say, Norvell coaching both? It's probably 4 wins of difference. AND, with a new coach now, we'll be more likely to win the Egg next year and in '21 too.
Would you rather beat OM this year and probably lose the next 2 EB's and 4 more overall games? I wouldn't. Call me a OM fan if you want, but I believe losing to OM and getting a new coach will lead to more total wins vs OM alone than if we pull Thursday out AND it will be better for the program overall
Getting a new coach will do more good for our program than OM winning the Egg Thursday will do for theirs. For that reason, even if you're motivated by 50% State fan and 50% OM hater, you should want us to lose
Last edited by the_real_MSU_is_us; 11-24-2019 at 10:51 AM.
-
Winning the egg will put extra effort on the firing process. Ole miss did it with cutcliffe and they took a lotta damage resulting in a disastrous hire. I think our situation is bettern now than their's was though. But I don't think we'll hafta cross that road.
-

Originally Posted by
the_real_MSU_is_us
How many loses overall is a win vs OM worth? Hypothetical: We can go 1-11 with a win over OM, OR 14-1 with a loss to OM, but we win the SEC and the national championships. Which do you pick? I'd argue anyone who picks 1-11 isn't a State fan at all, just an OM hater.
But, lets say it's 6-6 with a win over OM vs 7-5 with a loss to them. I'd probably pick the 6-6 myself because beating them is worth 2 wins, not 1.
Now let's ask this hypothetical: If Joe starts, what will our record be next year? What will it be in '21 with a new coach who has to dig out of the even bigger hole we'll be in after year 3 of Joe vs 2? Now, what would the record over the next 2 years be with say, Norvell coaching both? It's probably 4 wins of difference. AND, with a new coach now, we'll be more likely to win the Egg next year and in '21 too.
Would you rather beat OM this year and probably lose the next 2 EB's and 4 more overall games? I wouldn't. Call me a OM fan if you want, but I believe losing to OM and getting a new coach will lead to more total wins vs OM alone than if we pull Thursday out AND it will be better for the program overall
Getting a new coach will do more good for our program than OM winning the Egg Thursday will do for theirs. For that reason, even if you're motivated by 50% State fan and 50% OM hater, you should want us to lose
I can't stand OM and especially their football program. In just the last several years, I decided to pull for them to win against another team if it would benefit us. Prior to that I just wanted them to lose period, and that was against any team in any sport. You think what you want, but I'm looking at the current situation for right now and that is to beat OM if we possibly can. The other long term situation should work itself out for the betterment of our football program going forward.
Last edited by yjnkdawg; 11-24-2019 at 11:04 AM.
-
If we beat Ole Miss Joe will definitely be here next year. If he then goes 6-6 he?s here again, and again and again and again.
Change has to be forced. Counting on ADs to ?do the right thing? is naive at best.
-

Originally Posted by
cheewgumm
If we beat Ole Miss Joe will definitely be here next year. If he then goes 6-6 he?s here again, and again and again and again.
Change has to be forced. Counting on ADs to ?do the right thing? is naive at best.
That's not a definite but more like a possibility. However, possibilities don't always become a reality.
-
I?d like to not take that chance.
If we win and keep him, at least it will be a good lesson for our fans on ?the greater good?. Maybe it will help them the next time this happens.
-

Originally Posted by
yjnkdawg
You sure fooled me then, but I agree with not keeping a coach based upon one game. ----------"Egg Bowl - some of you are so worried about losing that game that you can?t see the big picture. Some of us on here are focused ahead."
Some believe he?s worth keeping if we win that game. But my mind is made up and I?m already set on the future regardless of what happens. Understand that now?
-
Dan the man is right. Pull for a win and hope he leaves. Based on Joe’s body language I imagine he probably wants to leave anyway and Rutgers is still open along with a couple of other jobs potentially.
So I’d say the odds of him leaving are really high win or lose.
-

Originally Posted by
cheewgumm
I?d like to not take that chance.
If we win and keep him, at least it will be a good lesson for our fans on ?the greater good?. Maybe it will help them the next time this happens.
Yeah. Because they learned that with Jackie in 2003 and Dan in 2015.
-

Originally Posted by
Todd4State
Yeah. Because they learned that with Jackie in 2003 and Dan in 2015.
What you mean by Dan in 2015. He went 9-4 that year. Maybe you meant 2016 but he then was one broken ankle away from 9-3 and with bowl win 10-3 (but he'd be gone by then).
-
I?m starting to think the smoke was right one Moorhead to Rutgers earlier this year but they used Sciano as a decoy to take all the attention off.
-

Originally Posted by
trojandawg
I?m starting to think the smoke was right one Moorhead to Rutgers earlier this year but they used Sciano as a decoy to take all the attention off.
Naw, they are having power struggle over control with the AD and what Schiano wants and with the board to approve the negotiations. It’s dragging on but it has nothing to do with Moorehead or any other coach
-

Originally Posted by
Really Clark?
Naw, they are having power struggle over control with the AD and what Schiano wants and with the board to approve the negotiations. It’s dragging on but it has nothing to do with Moorehead or any other coach
Doesn?t look like it?s Schiano
-

Originally Posted by
trojandawg
Doesn?t look like it?s Schiano
Looks that way and been trending as such the last 4-5 days but it had nothing to do with a smokescreen for another coach. Power struggle over control of the program. The AD didn’t have Schiano as his first choice to begin with
-

Originally Posted by
Cooterpoot
Any fan pulling against us this week is worthless. I believe we?re going to lose, but I?m damn sure not pulling for us to lose. That?s not big picture. That?s worthless ass fans.
Change is coming anyway.
Right on, Cooter!
-

Originally Posted by
Cowbell
The man thought his plan would work - it was obvious it wouldn?t work last year - he had an offseason to adjust and he didnt - he didnt realize our S&C was going downhill either. He didn?t realize he was being too soft. We have a coach that lacks discernment when it comes to the game. You can?t fix that with assistant changes. We can not continue to let him learn on the job and pay him 3 million. Especially when he is the last guy in the room to figure it out.
Listen closely. Football is a game that is won by staying one step ahead and we have a leader that is constantly 2 steps behind.
Egg Bowl - some of you are so worried about losing that game that you can?t see the big picture. Some of us on here are focused ahead - honestly this season is dead and over for me. It was part of a two year mistake that I hope we end on Friday.
He didn't know how you can adjust to stop KYs DE last year. It was insane not to block that dude. Or atleast put a te over there to chip him.
-

Originally Posted by
Cooterpoot
Any fan pulling against us this week is worthless. I believe we?re going to lose, but I?m damn sure not pulling for us to lose. That?s not big picture. That?s worthless ass fans.
Change is coming anyway.
I'm not pulling for us to lose either, but I think there is a good possibility we will. Maybe a good win will convince Rutgers Joe's the man for their job.
-

Originally Posted by
dawgday166
What you mean by Dan in 2015. He went 9-4 that year. Maybe you meant 2016 but he then was one broken ankle away from 9-3 and with bowl win 10-3 (but he'd be gone by then).
I mean our AD should have called Dan's bluff and forced him to leave after he totally checked out of the Egg Bowl that year. The result after that was a loss to South Alabama and another checked out Egg Bowl plus two-three half assed recruiting classes that we are having to deal with now.
-
Fans wanting to lose to Ole Miss baffles me. If your program is centered around 1 game, your program is screwed anyways regardless of the coach. It's was screwed before Moorhead, Mullen etc etc. I want to beat Ole Miss by 100.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
Disclaimer: Elitedawgs is a privately owned and operated forum that is managed by alumni of Mississippi State University. This website is in no way affiliated with the Mississippi State University, The Southeastern Conference (SEC) or the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). The views and opinions expressed herein are strictly those of the post author and may not reflect the views of other members of this forum or elitedawgs.com. The interactive nature of the elitedawgs.com forums makes it impossible for elitedawgs.com to assume responsibility for any of the content posted at this site. Ideas, thoughts, suggestion, comments, opinions, advice and observations made by participants at elitedawgs.com are not endorsed by elitedawgs.com
Elitedawgs: A Mississippi State Fan Forum, Mississippi State Football, Mississippi State Basketball, Mississippi State Baseball, Mississippi State Athletics. Mississippi State message board.