-
Originally Posted by
Really Clark?
You do know Purdue scored 31 on them and just got humiliated by LSU.
Don't curse at me when you can't read numbskull. I said exactly that it was our team that got 9 wins this season. But nobody can honestly say that Will is the reason we won 9 and not be lying. It was our team, our defense and special teams that got us to 9. Not Will and the offense solely. And BTW, if Will doesn't throw the pick in the end zone early in the game, we wouldn't have needed a 4th down TD. Good for him but he and the offense were the reason that for 3 quarters we were sucking hind tit. No to mention the other pick. The defense and special teams was 85% of the reason we won yesterday. But my original post was mainly about the team on all sides have to be giving equal credit at a min. My statement on yesterdays game was a perfect example of how the season played out in general as a whole. Defense and special teams carried us more so than the offense.
you do know Purdue only had a few Coaches left and had to bring in Drew to help. they were a team in disarray. if you think our offense didn't play a big part in the win-then your football IQ is pretty low.We drove for the win with under 2 minutes left. For sure in the first half -Will played pretty awful--but He played well and was clutch in the second half. Ok defense -won the game--but it was the offense that took control with under 2 minutes and scored ...
-
Originally Posted by
tcdog70
you do know Purdue only had a few Coaches left and had to bring in Drew to help. they were a team in disarray. if you think our offense didn't play a big part in the win-then your football IQ is pretty low.We drove for the win with under 2 minutes left. For sure in the first half -Will played pretty awful--but He played well and was clutch in the second half. Ok defense -won the game--but it was the offense that took control with under 2 minutes and scored ...
Again and for the last time, the post I responded to alluded that it was Will's ability that won us 9 games this season. That is not an accurate statement. Nobody can honestly state that we won 9 games on our QB's shoulders this season. I love Will but I can be objective about how we won our games this year and how each portion of the team did to achieve that.
-
Anyone taking up for Will Rogers on the field play this year is quite frankly football illiterate. Our defense has carried this team all year. We won in spite of our quarterback against Illinois, Auburn, and Ole Miss. We are above average quarterback play away from being a really really good football team. It is obvious.
-
Originally Posted by
Jarius
Anyone taking up for Will Rogers on the field play this year is quite frankly football illiterate. Our defense has carried this team all year. We won in spite of our quarterback against Illinois, Auburn, and Ole Miss. We are above average quarterback play away from being a really really good football team. It is obvious.
-
Originally Posted by
TaleofTwoDogs
Don't forget to bring his 10,000 yards of passing yards to his table of skills. Just saying.
With an average of like 5 yards per attempt. As many attempts as he has had, against 14 or so non-conference games and the 20 or so conference games, he should have 15k yards by now.
-
Originally Posted by
Jarius
Anyone taking up for Will Rogers on the field play this year is quite frankly football illiterate. Our defense has carried this team all year. We won in spite of our quarterback against Illinois, Auburn, and Ole Miss. We are above average quarterback play away from being a really really good football team. It is obvious.
Bingo. That is 100% correct. It is also unfortunate because Will is a great bulldog, but being a great bulldog doesn’t make it inaccurate.
-
Originally Posted by
Lord McBuckethead
With an average of like 5 yards per attempt. As many attempts as he has had, against 14 or so non-conference games and the 20 or so conference games, he should have 15k yards by now.
I get your point and know you were just throwing out a number but it is a little better. 6.5 this season and 6.9 last year for yards per attempt.
-
To me the worst stat in football is yards per attempt. It?s just stupid. In basketball do we consider the average score for a player based on attempts or made field goals?
You cannot hold every single attempted but incomplete pass against the QB. There is a player on each end of that equation. Same with interceptions. I think a catchable ball that a receiver mishandled that ends up in a defenders hands should be called a fumble, not an interception. But I also think Santa lives in Antarctica, so what do I know.
-
Originally Posted by
CaptainObvious
To me the worst stat in football is yards per attempt. It?s just stupid. In basketball do we consider the average score for a player based on attempts or made field goals?
You cannot hold every single attempted but incomplete pass against the QB. There is a player on each end of that equation. Same with interceptions. I think a catchable ball that a receiver mishandled that ends up in a defenders hands should be called a fumble, not an interception. But I also think Santa lives in Antarctica, so what do I know.
Huh? Yards per attempt is way more important than simply yards, just as FG% is way more important than simply points.
-
Originally Posted by
CaptainObvious
To me the worst stat in football is yards per attempt. It?s just stupid. In basketball do we consider the average score for a player based on attempts or made field goals?
You cannot hold every single attempted but incomplete pass against the QB. There is a player on each end of that equation. Same with interceptions. I think a catchable ball that a receiver mishandled that ends up in a defenders hands should be called a fumble, not an interception. But I also think Santa lives in Antarctica, so what do I know.
Holy shit this is stupid. Like.... unbelievable dumb.
Basketball uses True Shooting % to weight 2/3 points against people and definitely looks at usage rate. 30 points on 30 shots is considered inefficient and not as impressive as 25 points on 15 shots.
You literally used one of the biggest changes to modern basketball understanding to make the opposite point you're trying to make. Like wow.
-
Will has terrible footwork which impacts everything he's trying to do. Honestly, if that were to improve he could be a legitimate and respectable SEC quarterback. It's obvious from watching and listening to Leach's philosophy that wasn't important.
-
Since the Kentucky game (and excluding the ETSU game) Will's game averages:
30/48
259 yards
1.3 tds
.8 ints
2.5 sacks
5.4 ypa
Yuck. Something changed in that Kentucky game for him and his gameplay the rest of the season.
He was 8th in total qbr. His 6.5 YPA was .1 away from being DFL in SEC. He threw for the most yards in the sec, beating out Stetson Bennett by 151 yards - Stetson attempted 181 fewer passes than Will.
Objectively, Will wasn't good this year. We won the egg bowl and bowl game despite him. I'm tired of everyone treating him with kid gloves.
-
Originally Posted by
bulldawg28
Will has terrible footwork which impacts everything he's trying to do. Honestly, if that were to improve he could be a legitimate and respectable SEC quarterback. It's obvious from watching and listening to Leach's philosophy that wasn't important.
He throws flat footed, a lot
-
Will's stats in sec play vs OOC
SEC: 240/382 (63%)
14 td/4 int and 6 fumbles
2240 yds
280 ypg
5.9 ypa
59.6 QBR or 123 RTG (whichever you prefer)
OOC: 175/228 (77%)
21 td/4 int and 2 fumbles
1734 yds
346.8 ypg
7.6 ypa
70.8 QBR or 167.6 RTG
On average if he played a full SEC schedule his stats would be:
390/621 (63%)
23 td/7 int and 10 fumbles
3640 yds
same ypg, ypa, QBR and RTG as SEC above
-
Originally Posted by
msstate7
He throws flat footed, a lot
Hmmm, I'm not buying he has bad foot work, many times he is getting rid of the ball and there isn't much to do with foot work as it is squaring up and touch. If you never played QB then you shouldn't discuss fundamentals.
-
Originally Posted by
basedog
Hmmm, I'm not buying he has bad foot work, many times he is getting rid of the ball and there isn't much to do with foot work as it is squaring up and touch. If you never played QB then you shouldn't discuss fundamentals.
Lol, wut... Andy Reid never played qb either
Just watch his feet in the bowl game. He throws the ball with both feet planted a lot.
-
I wish there was somewhere I could get his statistics for throwing while on the run. I know that would be eye opening.
-
Originally Posted by
msstate7
Lol, wut... Andy Reid never played qb either
Just watch his feet in the bowl game. He throws the ball with both feet planted a lot.
Never heard Andy Reid discuss footwork with QB's either, he has a QB Coach. Flat footed may be on certain throws but Rogers doesn't have bad foot work overall. Mecanicas isn't always the same with every QB, same with a baseball pitcher or even a shooter in basketball. You can tweet fundamentals but it's not the same for everyone. Hell look at golf for another example. Arnold Palmer swing was weird!
-
Originally Posted by
basedog
Never heard Andy Reid discuss footwork with QB's either, he has a QB Coach. Flat footed may be on certain throws but Rogers doesn't have bad foot work overall. Mecanicas isn't always the same with every QB, same with a baseball pitcher or even a shooter in basketball. You can tweet fundamentals but it's not the same for everyone. Hell look at golf for another example. Arnold Palmer swing was weird!
I said he throws flat footed a lot, and that's what you quoted me on. That's all I said. He does, and that's a fact
ETA... Reid is/was a qb coach. Leach didn't play football qb either.
Last edited by msstate7; 01-05-2023 at 10:54 AM.
-
Originally Posted by
basedog
Hmmm, I'm not buying he has bad foot work, many times he is getting rid of the ball and there isn't much to do with foot work as it is squaring up and touch. If you never played QB then you shouldn't discuss fundamentals.
He's got bad footwork. Many times, he just stops his feet all together and then delivers a throw.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
Disclaimer: Elitedawgs is a privately owned and operated forum that is managed by alumni of Mississippi State University. This website is in no way affiliated with the Mississippi State University, The Southeastern Conference (SEC) or the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). The views and opinions expressed herein are strictly those of the post author and may not reflect the views of other members of this forum or elitedawgs.com. The interactive nature of the elitedawgs.com forums makes it impossible for elitedawgs.com to assume responsibility for any of the content posted at this site. Ideas, thoughts, suggestion, comments, opinions, advice and observations made by participants at elitedawgs.com are not endorsed by elitedawgs.com
Elitedawgs: A Mississippi State Fan Forum, Mississippi State Football, Mississippi State Basketball, Mississippi State Baseball, Mississippi State Athletics. Mississippi State message board.