-

Originally Posted by
confucius say
Hutzler has definitely improved. He can't catch the ball for Ellington and Mitchell.
Wish MVB would get down by diving forward instead of sliding. Difference in 3 yards. You're down when your hips begin to sink if you slide.
Have not seen a transfer qb we could realistically get as a 2-10/3-9 team that id rather have than MVB. That includes Arnold.
I think Arkansas is better than Missouri.
Well we are going to go after a transfer QB and it is probably going to be Jackson Arnold. That has been in the cards since he was replaced during the Tennessee game for them and Shapen went down.
-

Originally Posted by
StarkVegasSteve
Well we are going to go after a transfer QB and it is probably going to be Jackson Arnold. That has been in the cards since he was replaced during the Tennessee game for them and Shapen went down.
Who is he starting for????
-
1. Seriously doubt we go after Arnold. He's got baggage and wants a guaranteed starting spot. We don't need his drama.
2. We need a real DC on the worst way.
3. Recruiting on the defensive side has been awful minus a couple guys, especially the DL and Edge
4. Damn this offense will be great when we get an OL
Last edited by Cooterpoot; 10-21-2024 at 08:02 AM.
-

Originally Posted by
parabrave
Who is he starting for????
He'll compete with Van Buren. If Van Buren is as good as everyone on here thinks he is then he'll win the job. I do know for a fact that Arnold is not asking for a guaranteed starting spot. He was going to transfer out of all likelihood anyways. They went to OU SOLELY because of Lebby but they offered him the world to keep him so he wanted to stay for a year to see if they could make it work. If you had to ask me right now, Arnold wins the job. Familiarity with the offense and familiarity with Lebby. Lebby handpicked this guy to be his QB at Oklahoma after Gabriel.
-

Originally Posted by
StarkVegasSteve
He'll compete with Van Buren. If Van Buren is as good as everyone on here thinks he is then he'll win the job. I do know for a fact that Arnold is not asking for a guaranteed starting spot. He was going to transfer out of all likelihood anyways. They went to OU SOLELY because of Lebby but they offered him the world to keep him so he wanted to stay for a year to see if they could make it work. If you had to ask me right now, Arnold wins the job. Familiarity with the offense and familiarity with Lebby. Lebby handpicked this guy to be his QB at Oklahoma after Gabriel.
But now we have to worry about spending NIL in the right spots. And right now it seem we have more pressing needs than to have 2 high priced QBs because MVB price will probably go up..
-

Originally Posted by
parabrave
But now we have to worry about spending NIL in the right spots. And right now it seem we have more pressing needs than to have 2 high priced QBs because MVB price will probably go up..
And that's where I've stopped short of saying it's a guarantee that we'll get Arnold, Mateer, Stone, Brown, etc. If the price is driven up too much then we have to back out. You have to always be looking to improve your team AT EVERY POSITION. But you can't get greedy trying to upgrade one when it is to the detriment of another. I mean if Auburn offers Arnold the world, which they may do, we can't get into a bidding war with Jimmy Rane because that would be of detriment to what we need on the DL, OL, and in the secondary. However, we got the money to get in some bidding wars. We got plenty of it.
-
Arnold isn't likely coming here and he wouldn't beat out MVB anyway. He's wanting NIL, and he's going to go somewhere where he's guaranteed a spot. He's got some issues that we don't need here either. I won't be surprised if he's playing more again at OK with the OC change.
-

Originally Posted by
Cooterpoot
Arnold isn't likely coming here and he wouldn't beat out MVB anyway. He's wanting NIL, and he's going to go somewhere where he's guaranteed a spot. He's got some issues that we don't need here either. I won't be surprised if he's playing more again at OK with the OC change.
And he may. He's a lot closer to JJF than he ever was to Littrell. The family didn't like Littrell. I do think he transfers though. And I believe it will be here or Auburn. Baylor is a wild card depending on who they hire after Arranda gets canned, but I believe it comes down to those two schools. They want to stay in the SEC.
-

Originally Posted by
StarkVegasSteve
He'll compete with Van Buren. If Van Buren is as good as everyone on here thinks he is then he'll win the job. I do know for a fact that Arnold is not asking for a guaranteed starting spot. He was going to transfer out of all likelihood anyways. They went to OU SOLELY because of Lebby but they offered him the world to keep him so he wanted to stay for a year to see if they could make it work. If you had to ask me right now, Arnold wins the job. Familiarity with the offense and familiarity with Lebby. Lebby handpicked this guy to be his QB at Oklahoma after Gabriel.
Having another option at QB would be great, but I can't imagine that's going to be a priority when we've got a promising young QB, unless we don't think Van Buren will stay. Much better to roll the dice and know that we're screwed if Van Buren gets hurt than to pass on upgrading defense because we want to make sure we have a qb competition and a good backup. Could very well end up having NIL tied up in a backup that never plays while our lack of defensive talent ensures we can't win against decent teams.
-

Originally Posted by
Johnson85
Having another option at QB would be great, but I can't imagine that's going to be a priority when we've got a promising young QB, unless we don't think Van Buren will stay. Much better to roll the dice and know that we're screwed if Van Buren gets hurt than to pass on upgrading defense because we want to make sure we have a qb competition and a good backup. Could very well end up having NIL tied up in a backup that never plays while our lack of defensive talent ensures we can't win against decent teams.
Again, I'm not saying go overspend to have a QB. I am saying that we are going to go get a QB and there will be a competition. I mean why are people not saying that we need to pull Kamario Taylor's scholarship since Van Buren is only a freshman. I mean half of y'all were telling me a month ago that Taylor was better than Van Buren and Van Buren would never play. Now we have to go balls to the walls to make sure there's no competition.
-
I think we need healthy competition with the QBs but spending a ton on Arnold would be stupid. There will be a few good QBs on the market we could probably snag cheaper. Van Buren has the team more so than I thought. I've definitely cooled on bringing Arnold in as option, especially if he expects a starting job. I'd much rather money go to the defensive side of the ball. We are a corner, edge rusher and maybe a stout blitzing LB from a good defense. Oh, and a DC that knows what he's doing.
-

Originally Posted by
TrapGame
I think we need healthy competition with the QBs but spending a ton on Arnold would be stupid. There will be a few good QBs on the market we could probably snag cheaper. Van Buren has the team more so than I thought. I've definitely cooled on bringing Arnold in as option, especially if he expects a starting job. I'd much rather money go to the defensive side of the ball. We are a corner, edge rusher and maybe a stout blitzing LB from a good defense. Oh, and a DC that knows what he's doing.
That I agree with. If the tag is too pricey, or he wants a guaranteed spot then you pass. We can go find a guy who will want to compete as there will be more than a few out there. However, we have money to spend on a top QB and money to go get top tier defensive talent.
-
Surely we spend our money on defense and o lineman, not another QB.
-

Originally Posted by
Matt3467
Saw these stats posted elsewhere:
Out of 133 FBS teams, we are:
#133 Sacks
#130 TFLs
#130 3rd Down DEF
#122 Total DEF
#121 Passing Efficiency DEF
#117 Scoring DEF
#114 Rush DEF
#112 Passing Yards Allowed
Talent or not we have the worst DC in the country. We can tell ourselves Hutzler has been improving and maybe has although he certainly couldn't get worse.
I've been off the Hutzler train since Florida.
But it's hard to know what he is capable of when we have G5 defense talent wise, at best. Actually, we have guys playing that couldn't get in the field at G5 schools last year.
I'm good with moving on, but it's way more a talent problem than coaching.
-

Originally Posted by
TrapGame
3rd and 23, Hutz rushes three. WTF?
Not bringing the house there is criminal. If Weigman hit a receiver before someone got him, so be it, but not bringing everyone on that play is just inept, shit coaching.
We are a competent defensive coordinator away from being a good team. Talent? Yeah, we need some but we need a guy that knows what to do with what he's got.
So you want to play cover 0 there? That's probably 6 if you do that with our secondary.
I mean I'm not against trying it at this point, but we don't have the talent to run it so just as likely to not work as dropping 8.
Last edited by confucius say; 10-21-2024 at 10:37 AM.
-

Originally Posted by
StarkVegasSteve
Well we are going to go after a transfer QB and it is probably going to be Jackson Arnold. That has been in the cards since he was replaced during the Tennessee game for them and Shapen went down.
Ok. That's risky though. Personally I would not.
-

Originally Posted by
confucius say
So you want to play cover 0 there? That's probably 6 of you do with our secondary.
I mean I'm not against trying it at this point, but we don't have the talent to run it so just as likely to not work as dropping 8.
Dropping 8 did absolutely DICK. Bring the ****ing house. If he beats you, he beats. Dropping 8 on 3rd and 23 was bending over. Those three dropped interceptions we had were b/c we actually got some pressure on Weigman.
-
I think it's funny that you are worried about MVB sliding as if him getting hurt would make a damn in this season. We are going 2-10 or 3-9 anyway. Who gives a sh*T if he gets hurt running the offense at this point? It literally does not matter. The people yelling at him for sliding are right. He doesn't need to be an idiot and play like Corral, but he needs to run the offense and stop acting like it matters to this team or season if he happens to get hurt doing so.
-
So what's going on with Shapen? I thought I heard somewhere he was trying for another year of eligibility?
-

Originally Posted by
Jarius
I think it's funny that you are worried about MVB sliding as if him getting hurt would make a damn in this season. We are going 2-10 or 3-9 anyway. Who gives a sh*T if he gets hurt running the offense at this point? It literally does not matter. The people yelling at him for sliding are right. He doesn't need to be an idiot and play like Corral, but he needs to run the offense and stop acting like it matters to this team or season if he happens to get hurt doing so.
Because if we look like hell on offense, the current skill players we have, who are good by the way, will transfer. I mean if we run Parson out there, who apparently can't complete a forward pass or Jake Weir, who I know would get killed in an actual D1 football game, we will look like hell. Let's keep our QB healthy and actually look good on offense.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
Disclaimer: Elitedawgs is a privately owned and operated forum that is managed by alumni of Mississippi State University. This website is in no way affiliated with the Mississippi State University, The Southeastern Conference (SEC) or the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). The views and opinions expressed herein are strictly those of the post author and may not reflect the views of other members of this forum or elitedawgs.com. The interactive nature of the elitedawgs.com forums makes it impossible for elitedawgs.com to assume responsibility for any of the content posted at this site. Ideas, thoughts, suggestion, comments, opinions, advice and observations made by participants at elitedawgs.com are not endorsed by elitedawgs.com
Elitedawgs: A Mississippi State Fan Forum, Mississippi State Football, Mississippi State Basketball, Mississippi State Baseball, Mississippi State Athletics. Mississippi State message board.