If I had to choose between Favre or Rogers I'd go with Favre, I think his personality is so much better and players play hard with him. Not taking anything away from Rogers but I just see Favre having fun and no doubt he would have run for a TD on GB last possession. Most talented is like a beauty contest, not always most talent or most beautiful is in the best interest. Favre had that "IT Factor", way more than many imo.
Dak has some of what Favre had, I'm not sure he will be as good or great as Favre.

Man give me Payton, Rice and Favre all day long and twice on Sunday!