Auburn/Florida Thread

[msstate7]

So what do you think QBs rankings should be based on?

How they'll perform in college

[dantheman4248]

From my living room that night he showed zero emotion. And was out there yucking it up with Coach Meatloaf while they carted his QB off the field.

Did he get livid when they tried to do the same thing to KT a few plays later?

“From my living room”

Enough said. If you don’t see it on TV then it didn’t happen. As another person who was there mullen was one of the angriest.

[Liverpooldawg]

So what do you think QBs rankings should be based on?

Wins

[RocketDawg]

Trask is back.

[ShotgunDawg]

How they'll perform in college

Then just rank the blue blood commits all 5 stars. Rank the Oklahoma commit a 5 star #1 QB every year regardless of his skill set

See the issue there?

That's why I think the only way to do it & to attempt to guess the NFL draft order of QBs. It's hard no doubt

[Liverpooldawg]

Glad someone else saw it. The ol tackles the guy into the qb

Yeah, that one should have been a holding call on Florida.

[ShotgunDawg]

Wins

Woof. So, AJ McCarron & McElroy should've been 5*s when both were marginal talents?

[IMissJack]

It ain't easy to hire someone at MSU. It sucks but it is what it is. Our fans make it even harder than it has to be.

Our disgruntled fans are baby stuff compared to some schools.

[Commercecomet24]

Yeah, that one should have been a holding call on Florida.

Yeah it was pretty blatant too

[Liverpooldawg]

Woof. So, AJ McCarron & McElroy should've been 5*s when both were marginal talents?

I told you, I don't care about the NFL, at all. I judge college quarterbacks on wins. It's kind of like US Grant as a general. He wasn't as skilled as Lee in tactics in war, but he knew what he had to do to win, and did it. When he moved up to the next level, he didn't fare so well. But in the Civil War, he was a winner.

[TrapGame]

He threw a damn fit. I was THERE and saw it. You weren't but know more I guess. Our fans..........

Liver...

He's throwing a fit. Then within the span of five minutes, if that, he's laughing with Coach Kool-Aid Man like they're just talking about the weather. And Nick's career is, at that point, all but over. They would have had to restrain me from getting in Coach Fat Ass's face calling him a dirty m'fer.

But, I guess that was the perfect time to break the news to Luke. I'm sure Dan started whistling Rocky Top around him waiting for him to ask why.

[dawgday166]

Then just rank the blue blood commits all 5 stars. Rank the Oklahoma commit a 5 star #1 QB every year regardless of his skill set

See the issue there?

That's why I think the only way to do it & to attempt to guess the NFL draft order of QBs. It's hard no doubt

As Mullen said on Gameday today. The most important ingredient in a good QB is how fast they process information between the ears. And that's impossible to judge in HS. And it has to be processed faster in pros than college. And then they also have to be able to handle the pressure too

[TrapGame]

“From my living room”

Enough said. If you don’t see it on TV then it didn’t happen. As another person who was there mullen was one of the angriest.

Anger that evaporated like water.

Folks that was show.

[Liverpooldawg]

Liver...

He's throwing a fit. Then within the span of five minutes, if that, he's laughing with Coach Kool-Aid Man like they're just talking about the weather. And Nick's career is, at that point, all but over. They would have had to restrain me from getting in Coach Fat Ass's face calling him a dirty m'fer.

But, I guess that was the perfect time to break the news to Luke. I'm sure Dan started whistling Rocky Top around him waiting for him to ask why.

You weren't there by your own admission so you by definition have absolutely no idea what you are talking about, but you are doubling down anyway. If you aren't already in politics you should consider it. You would go far.

[ShotgunDawg]

I told you, I don't care about the NFL, at all. I judge college quarterbacks on wins. It's kind of like US Grant as a general. He wasn't as skilled as Lee in tactics in war, but he knew what he had to do to win, and did it. When he moved up to the next level, he didn't fare so well. But in the Civil War, he was a winner.

That's fine but I just don't think that gets us closer to the answer of finding out who the best QBs are.

I also don't care that you don't care about the NFL. Fact is, the NFL is a fairly objective measure upon which we can compare recruiting rankings to.

[Commercecomet24]

Liver...

He's throwing a fit. Then within the span of five minutes, if that, he's laughing with Coach Kool-Aid Man like they're just talking about the weather. And Nick's career is, at that point, all but over. They would have had to restrain me from getting in Coach Fat Ass's face calling him a dirty m'fer.

But, I guess that was the perfect time to break the news to Luke. I'm sure Dan started whistling Rocky Top around him waiting for him to ask why.

Coach kool aid man! Awesome!

Luke has always reminded me of private pyle from full metal jacket(Dennis D'Onfrio)

[ShotgunDawg]

As Mullen said on Gameday today. The most important ingredient in a good QB is how fast they process information between the ears. And that's impossible to judge in HS. And it has to be processed faster in pros than college. And then they also have to be able to handle the pressure too

Agree. It's terribly hard & #1 reason why all those Elite 11 camps are complete BS that don't actually help anyone rank the QBs

Again, every other sports recruits get ranked based on their pro prospect status.

PG rankings & Basketball stars are awarded based on the rankers guessing their prospect status. Why is football different? Just because it's hard?

[Liverpooldawg]

As Mullen said on Gameday today. The most important ingredient in a good QB is how fast they process information between the ears. And that's impossible to judge in HS. And it has to be processed faster in pros than college. And then they also have to be able to handle the pressure too

Absolutely correct.

[TrapGame]

You weren't there by your own admission so you by definition have absolutely no idea what you are talking about, but you are doubling down anyway. If you aren't already in politics you should consider it. You would go far.

Okay, Eyewitness News you win.**

[Liverpooldawg]

That's fine but I just don't think that gets us closer to the answer of finding out who the best QBs are.

I also don't care that you don't care about the NFL. Fact is, the NFL is a fairly objective measure upon which we can compare recruiting rankings to.

And it's all about wins there too.