Quote Originally Posted by BrunswickDawg View Post
I think you have to differentiate between Murphy and Kingman because of the awards. Kingman was an All-Star three times, no MVPS. He was not considered a dominate player of his era. He led the AL in HR twice but never got above 11th in MVP voting even in his best season.
Murphy also has a career 46.5 WAR to Kingman's 17.3 WAR.