-

Originally Posted by
Quaoarsking
If he starts every game through the 2024 season, he'll own every NCAA passing record. Mark it down.
Agree
-

Originally Posted by
MBDawg601
The moment you realize you have lost the debate, start straying off topic.
Good day sir.
Obviously Bucky.
Bested.
😂😂😂😂
-

Originally Posted by
Quaoarsking
If he starts every game through the 2024 season, he'll own every NCAA passing record. Mark it down.
Passer rating included? That's the stat that makes all qbs equal as a passer, regardless of difference in passing attempts. It's the gold standard imo
-
Some of you guys never played QB, need to stop talking about not knowing about a position you have no idea what it's like.
Yes Will is not real athletic but he is smart and very accurate. And no not anyone could fit into Leach's system.
If u disagree go outside and just throw a football in a tire from say 15 yards. LOL
QB is hardest position on the field.
-

Originally Posted by
dawgday166
So were Joe Montana's his 1st two SB years. Just saying. Will's ypa last night was 8.68.
He played well last night IMO. Odom had 2 weeks to game plan for us. Will threw an early pick but really didn't beat us early on and he a and WRs adjusted and made some plays as tame went on.
ETA: In fact both really good Coordinators 2 weeks and they used it too according to Pittman.
Look, Bucky, I agree that Will is not losing us games. Read it again slowly- WILL IS NOT THE REASON WE LOST THE GAME. He?s a very good system QB in the right system. That?s typically a recipe for success. That being said, outside of his grit and toughness, there is very little special about him that couldn?t be replaced by almost any other D1 college QB with similar grit. He?s doing what he?s being asked to do and that?s good enough to put us in position to win.
-

Originally Posted by
msstate7
Passer rating included? That's the stat that makes all qbs equal as a passer, regardless of difference in passing attempts. It's the gold standard imo
We know, you bring it up anytime someone mentions a stat about Will.
-

Originally Posted by
basedog
Some of you guys never played QB, need to stop talking about not knowing about a position you have no idea what it's like.
Yes Will is not real athletic but he is smart and very accurate. And no not anyone could fit into Leach's system.
If u disagree go outside and just throw a football in a tire from say 15 yards. LOL
QB is hardest position on the field.
Well, if high level playing experience is a pre req for being able to talk football, this place should shut down today. Where?d you play QB in college? Pros?
-

Originally Posted by
BrunswickDawg
We know, you bring it up anytime someone mentions a stat about Will.
Here's the passer rating leader nationally since 2012
2021: McCall
2020: mac Jones
2019: burrow
2018: tua
2017: mayfield
2016: mayfield
2015: Vernon Adams
2014: mariota
2013: Winston
2012: Winston
I'd say there's a strong correlation between great passer rating and great ability
-
Will is going to be a legend but he?s still developing. It seems to take him about a quarter to warm up. The problem is that quarter usually puts us 7-10 points in the hole and we are playing from behind. He needs to come out of the gate playing like he does in quarters 2.5 - 4. That will come with seasoning and experience I?m sure.
-
Will will be our Graham Harrell and there?s absolutely nothing wrong with that.
-

Originally Posted by
msstate7
Here's the passer rating leader nationally since 2012
2021: McCall
2020: mac Jones
2019: burrow
2018: tua
2017: mayfield
2016: mayfield
2015: Vernon Adams
2014: mariota
2013: Winston
2012: Winston
I'd say there's a strong correlation between great passer rating and great ability
Be careful using too much logic on people high on emotion.
-

Originally Posted by
Dak Holliday
Look, Bucky, I agree that Will is not losing us games. Read it again slowly- WILL IS NOT THE REASON WE LOST THE GAME. He?s a very good system QB in the right system. That?s typically a recipe for success. That being said, outside of his grit and toughness, there is very little special about him that couldn?t be replaced by almost any other D1 college QB with similar grit. He?s doing what he?s being asked to do and that?s good enough to put us in position to win.
Right now he's playing better than any QB in the conference. He has to keep it up. But if you think any other D1 QB can replace him ... you don't know a thing about QB play. Some could. But Arky's couldn't. Neither can KY's, FL's, etc. What is really impressive to me more than anything ... is how much better his movement when pressured has become, how well he's slipping and sliding in the pocket under pressure, how well he's finding his 4th option when on the move, and how damn accurate he's been the last 2 games on the move. He's really seeing the field well now. He's made some really difficult throws lately while on the move and hit his WR right where he needed to.
And I'm not saying he's Montana either ... it took me about Brady's 7th SB for me to put him in Montana's category.
At the beginning of year I wasn't sure he'd be our long term solution at QB and had a quite a few doubts myself. But I also took into account that he's a true soph, which most don't on this board. They want our true sophs to step on the field and play like Bama RS sophs or Jrs. Or Oline was not playing that well to start season either.
Last edited by dawgday166; 11-07-2021 at 10:21 AM.
-

Originally Posted by
Dak Holliday
Obviously Bucky.
Bested.
😂😂😂😂
Dude what is your problem? If you think I care so much about this board and your opinion of will to make not 1 but 2 accounts on here you care about this a lot more than I do.
-

Originally Posted by
Dak Holliday
Be careful using too much logic on people high on emotion.
Great, so based off of this logic and this logic alone.
Will Rogers has been the 2nd best qb in the conference the past two weeks.
Edit: I stand corrected. Wk 9 he was top. Emory Jones was up there for some reason.
Last edited by MBDawg601; 11-07-2021 at 10:24 AM.
-
Will does not need me to defend him, all he has done is prove some on here wrong every step of the way.
-

Originally Posted by
BuckyIsAB****
Will does not need me to defend him, all he has done is prove some on here wrong every step of the way.
Just so's you know ... I wouldn't trade Will for any QB in conference right now. Hell probably in the country but then I haven't watched all the QBs in the country either.
-
I like you intentionally swapping accounts back to back on my account, Bucky, in an attempt to put Batman and Bruce Wayne in the same room at the same time. 😂
Will?s numbers in this system have him ranked at number 2. That?s awesome, but he?s not even in a top QB conversation. Maybe he will be next year, but you don?t have to push him so hard on us like he?s your kid. I know you can?t stand criticism, but you?re so far gone that you can?t even stand a complementary statement that doesn?t claim that he?s better than Dak.
-

Originally Posted by
dawgday166
Just so's you know ... I wouldn't trade Will for any QB in conference right now.
Wow.
Yeah, I'd take young, either of Georgia's, or corral without a second thought.
ETA... and then you doubled down and said country. You've gone off the deep end
-

Originally Posted by
basedog
Some of you guys never played QB, need to stop talking about not knowing about a position you have no idea what it's like.
Yes Will is not real athletic but he is smart and very accurate. And no not anyone could fit into Leach's system.
If u disagree go outside and just throw a football in a tire from say 15 yards. LOL
QB is hardest position on the field.
The one's you talking about ... would just wilt under the pressure of trying to throw it thru the tire. But they experts on this board.
-
Oh, and Buck, just use your regular account. You?re better than a burner account to talk on here. Save that for Twitter.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
Disclaimer: Elitedawgs is a privately owned and operated forum that is managed by alumni of Mississippi State University. This website is in no way affiliated with the Mississippi State University, The Southeastern Conference (SEC) or the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). The views and opinions expressed herein are strictly those of the post author and may not reflect the views of other members of this forum or elitedawgs.com. The interactive nature of the elitedawgs.com forums makes it impossible for elitedawgs.com to assume responsibility for any of the content posted at this site. Ideas, thoughts, suggestion, comments, opinions, advice and observations made by participants at elitedawgs.com are not endorsed by elitedawgs.com
Elitedawgs: A Mississippi State Fan Forum, Mississippi State Football, Mississippi State Basketball, Mississippi State Baseball, Mississippi State Athletics. Mississippi State message board.