Cupp is supposed to be a fielder, not a hitter. This year his fielding hasn't been good. But his hitting has been better than expected. He has a decent average, has some doubles, has walked a lot, and has been hit by a lot of pitches. His OBP is great for a #9 hitter. He's done the job at the plate. We haven't seen the last of Cupp.
Downs has played like Tarzan against the bad nonconference teams, and played like Jane against the good teams. He can't hit good pitching.
Chance is a nice player, he's just limited from a talent perspective.