Hartfield vS Prep tonight for all the marbles

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Coursesuper

Prep would struggle to stay on the field with any team in 6A or 7A. Good 5A would have their way with them. Too many athletes.

---

Rivals, 247 and MaxPreps disagree with you. They have Prep ranked 2nd only behind Brandon. Last time I checked they look at talent

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by somebodyshotmypaw

MRA beat 7A Oak Grove 51-13. MRA lost to Prep 42-17.

---

Off year for Oak Grove and others to cherry pick from. Come on up and play Tupelo, Starkville, Louisville etc. I?ve heard this forever. Never changes.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SilentSteel16

Boy what a burn, when you resort to spelling nazi you really do not have a leg to stand on do ya.

Yes I believe Prep,Hartfield and MRA would beat all the teams you just listed almost every time. I am public school guy, but you have to give credit where it is due and you can no longer stand on the argument that private schools don’t have the athletes that public schools do. That is a very outdated way of thinking.

Just a bad take plain and simple.

---

Weird. Took you for a private school guy like myself. Again like I said, just my opinion. I have watched Prep and was just not impressed. More impressed with Hartfield between the two. Heath built them a good team. I just think depth will take over most of the time with private vs public matchups. Prep and Hartfield have bigger rosters than most private schools but eventually those lineman get tired of trying to tackle and missing an athlete like Kamario Taylor

Regardless of whatever misconceptions of some, this has been a great game. Tons of talent on both sides of the ball. Number 2 for Hartfield might even be the best athlete on the field tonight. He is not even one of the headliners.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SilentSteel16

Rivals, 247 and MaxPreps disagree with you. They have Prep ranked 2nd only behind Brandon. Last time I checked they look at talent

---

And Magnolia Heights never ranked above 8th in the state in baseball last year and I know for a fact Magnolia would have beat the hell out of any team in the state last year. So apparently they only look at talent in certain situations.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Coursesuper

Off year for Oak Grove and others to cherry pick from. Come on up and play Tupelo, Starkville, Louisville etc. I?ve heard this forever. Never changes.

---

That’s not cherry picking that was the outcome of a game this year. Only ones to choose from.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SilentSteel16

Regardless of whatever misconceptions of some, this has been a great game. Tons of talent on both sides of the ball. Number 2 for Hartfield might even be the best athlete on the field tonight. He is not even one of the headliners.

---

What is the score? Have not seen anything today. Watched Parklane drop a 70 burger on Leake yesterday. Looked like our defense trying to stop teams.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RezDog7

I've been wondering for a while but now I'm convinced that you're Steve Robertson. Good lord what a terrible take. Hartfield would beat the shit out of those teams.

---

I am indeed not Steve Robertson. I shower regularly, do not wear a damn top hat, and do not think John Cohen was a great AD.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by StarkVegasSteve

Weird. Took you for a private school guy like myself. Again like I said, just my opinion. I have watched Prep and was just not impressed. More impressed with Hartfield between the two. Heath built them a good team. I just think depth will take over most of the time with private vs public matchups. Prep and Hartfield have bigger rosters than most private schools but eventually those lineman get tired of trying to tackle and missing an athlete like Kamario Taylor

---

Well I guess that would be the 2nd time your assumptions are incorrect tonight. McComb High graduate here. Can’t get more “public” than that considering the State took over the school. Haha.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SilentSteel16

Regardless of whatever misconceptions of some, this has been a great game. Tons of talent on both sides of the ball. Number 2 for Hartfield might even be the best athlete on the field tonight. He is not even one of the headliners.

---

Braylon Womack #2 is a top 20 prospect in the country for 2026 and rated a 98 on 247 with offers from every blue blood I the country, he?s a stud. Everything else I agree with you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SilentSteel16

Well I guess that would be the 2nd time your assumptions are incorrect tonight. McComb High graduate here. Can’t get more “public” than that considering the State took over the school. Haha.

---

Yea that makes you pretty public to say the least haha

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Coursesuper

Off year for Oak Grove and others to cherry pick from. Come on up and play Tupelo, Starkville, Louisville etc. I?ve heard this forever. Never changes.

---

But you said ANY 6A or 7A teams. Oak Grove qualifies as any 6A or 7A team.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by StarkVegasSteve

What is the score? Have not seen anything today. Watched Parklane drop a 70 burger on Leake yesterday. Looked like our defense trying to stop teams.

---

7 to 7 at halftime. Both lines are doing a great job against the rush but the depth might be more of a problem for Hatfield because majority of their guys are playing Ironman football. Tremendous athletes though. I believe the JA network is live-streaming it. If Prep’s QB was a few inches taller you would know his name more recruiting wise. He has a great and accurate arm. Both teams Kickers will be Power 4 guys as well.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SilentSteel16

7 to 7 at halftime. Both lines are doing a great job against the rush but the depth might be more of a problem for Hatfield because majority of their guys are playing Ironman football. Tremendous athletes though. I believe the JA network is live-streaming it. If Prep’s QB was a few inches taller you would know his name more recruiting wise. He has a great and accurate arm. Both teams Kickers will be Power 4 guys as well.

---

Their QB is accurate with the ball. I think someone at the G5 level will take a flier on him. He is smart with the ball on top of being accurate c

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by StarkVegasSteve

I feel pretty confident in saying that Noxubee Co, East Webster, and Choctaw Central would run both of those teams off the field. Tupelo would also dust them. They can probably hang with some public school teams but there would be plenty of games they would be out athleted.

---

Youre on crack if you think that. And if you seriously do then anything you say going forward about sports just got taken down several notches on being credible in my book.

Ive got family and friends that coach at D1 schools and they completely disagree with your take based on recruiting players in this state

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by msugolf

Youre on crack if you think that. And if you seriously do then anything you say going forward about sports just got taken down several notches on being credible in my book.

Ive got family and friends that coach at D1 schools and they completely disagree with your take based on recruiting players in this state

---

I have plenty of friends that recruit in this state as well and they all say the same thing. The top end talent in the private schools have gotten 100x better in the last 15 years, but overall they still have more guys starting at their schools that would not make the team at the bigger public schools in the state. Again, what Hubert Davis has built at MRA is incredible, but I do not think they could hang with a Tupelo, Starkville, etc. What Doug Goodwin has done st Prep to revitalize them is really impressive, but I do not think they could hang with Brandon.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by StarkVegasSteve

I have plenty of friends that recruit in this state as well and they all say the same thing. The top end talent in the private schools have gotten 100x better in the last 15 years, but overall they still have more guys starting at their schools that would not make the team at the bigger public schools in the state. Again, what Hubert Davis has built at MRA is incredible, but I do not think they could hang with a Tupelo, Starkville, etc. What Doug Goodwin has done st Prep to revitalize them is really impressive, but I do not think they could hang with Brandon.

---

You have changed from them being run off the field by Choctaw Central to not hanging with Tupelo and Brandon. That is two different discussions.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by somebodyshotmypaw

You have changed from them being run off the field by Choctaw Central to not hanging with Tupelo and Brandon. That is two different discussions.

---

Sorry you are right. I should have stuck with my original teams. I was trying to call out the Jackson private schools for how they have brought up talent.I got caught up in different conversations. I do still think Choctaw Central would run away from those teams and to me it would come down to depth and they have no one who can guard Cunningham. Like I said, I think the top end talent at those schools is the same and against a team like Choctaw I would probably give the nod to a Hartfield, but I think depth would win out. Also, man I would love to see Davis’ offense turned loose with Kamario Taylor at QB. They would be hell on wheels.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by StarkVegasSteve

Sorry you are right. I should have stuck with my original teams. I was trying to call out the Jackson private schools for how they have brought up talent.I got caught up in different conversations. I do still think Choctaw Central would run away from those teams and to me it would come down to depth and they have no one who can guard Cunningham. Like I said, I think the top end talent at those schools is the same and against a team like Choctaw I would probably give the nod to Hartfield, but I think depth would win out. Also, man I would love to see Davis’ offense turned loose with Kamario Taylor at QB. They would be hell on wheels.

---

Choctaw Central went 6-4 this year

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by somebodyshotmypaw

Choctaw Central went 6-4 this year

---

Sorry. I meant County and not Central. My bad on that one.