Question for the crootin Gurus RE: MSU's starting 22 compared to TSUN's

[Bully13]

what would the signing day star counts look like?

[capofirstfret]

Ask and you shall receive:
(Disclaimer: starting lineups were taken from August Clarion Ledger depth charts for both teams and the recruiting rankings all taken from 247Sports)

https://i.imgur.com/PJZaC4O.jpg

[Bully13]

Based on opening day rosters

QB MSU 3 star tsun 5 star

RB MSU 4 star tsun 4 star

WR MSU 4 star, (2) 3 stars tsun (3) 4 stars

TE MSU 3 star tsun 3 star

OL MSU (1) 4 star (juco) (1) 2 star (3) 3 stars tsun (1) 5 star (2) 4 stars (2) 3 stars

DL & LB (1) 5 star (4) 4 stars (2) 3 stars tsun (1) 5 star (4) 3 stars couldn't find Marquis Haynes

Safey & CB's all 3 stars except Jamal Peters 4 star tsun (1) 4 star and the rest 3 stars

edited,,,looks like Missed Gerri Green's 4 star

all in all they out star us at QB, WR & OL and we out star them with DL and LB's and equal at RB's and defensive back field

however even though we had a better ranked class last year, their 2016 & 2015 classes were much higher

the bottom line is that we've developed talent better however I realize this year they are in a mental collapse with no quality coaching.

[IMissJack]

Their running back is a 4 star? Admittedly I don't follow their recruiting, but I haven't seen him do anything.