Tom Luginbill w/ESPN on Bear Wilson, Duke Williams & Laquon Treadwell

[Out of Bounds]

Luginbill discussed SEC WRs on the Out of Bounds today.

PODCAST: http://*******/1g6LJdD
Out of Bounds Radio App w PODCAST: http://*******/1l69XZN

Thanks,
Bo

Bo Bounds
Out of Bounds Show
ESPN 105.9 The Zone
Live stream: thezone1059.com
Twitter: @bobounds
Jackson, MS

[Dawg496]

Synopsis anyone?

[cheewgumm]

Treadwell> Williams> Wilson

The end.

[Rayburn8]

Treadwell> Williams> Wilson

The end.
I would have Williams(small gap), Treadwell(smaller gap) Wilson. Wilson is and will be a monster but Duke is probably the best WR in the country. However, this is of course assuming Treadwell comes back as good as he was pre-injury.

[Interpolation_Dawg_EX]

Treadwell and Williams were Top rated WR's coming out of high school, while Bear is still learning the position and was recruited as a TE by some schools. It says a lot if he is already in the same conversation with those guys while still learning the position.

[PSYCHO(thesis)DEFENSE]

Treadwell> Williams> Wilson

The end.

That's more an order of who he said was more polished. My interpretation was that Luginbill views Williams as the better player & specimen versus Treadwell, just less polished at playing the position. He seems to view Bear as a pure possession/ jump ball guy, didn't really hit on how he will continue to develop as a receiver. Personally, I think Bear's strength & tackle breaking ability makes up for a lack of quick twitch elusiveness, both w/ & w/o the ball.

[MSUDawg4Life]

Duke Williams Stats:

45 catches 730 yards 5 touchdowns

Bear Wilson Stats:

47 catches 680 yards 9 touchdowns

And Bear is not even in the same conversation? Are you sure about that, Tom Luginbill? Let's not even mention that Bear is a true sophomore that only played one year of high school football.

GTFOHWTBS!

[TUSK]

was it just about SECW WRs?

If not, I'd expect to see Pharoh Cooper at, or near, the top....

[MSUDawg4Life]

was it just about SECW WRs?

If not, I'd expect to see Pharoh Cooper at, or near, the top....

No. They just compared Treadwell, Wilson and Williams.

[TUSK]

No. They just compared Treadwell, Wilson and Williams.

Roger that.... Thanks!

[Bama_Dawg]

Just keep sleeping on the Dawgs....

[Just This Once]

Duke Williams Stats:

45 catches 730 yards 5 touchdowns

Bear Wilson Stats:

47 catches 680 yards 9 touchdowns

And Bear is not even in the same conversation? Are you sure about that, Tom Luginbill? Let's not even mention that Bear is a true sophomore that only played one year of high school football.

GTFOHWTBS!

To be fair, Bear was our top guy last year while Williams was behind Coates and about even with Bray until he got injured.

[MSUDawg4Life]

To be fair, Bear was our top guy last year while Williams was behind Coates and about even with Bray until he got injured.

Sammie Coates stats:

34 catches 741 yards 4 touchdowns

Quin Bray's stats:

39 catches 471 yards 4 touchdowns

*drops mic*

[maroonmania]

Duke Williams Stats:

45 catches 730 yards 5 touchdowns

Bear Wilson Stats:

47 catches 680 yards 9 touchdowns

And Bear is not even in the same conversation? Are you sure about that, Tom Luginbill? Let's not even mention that Bear is a true sophomore that only played one year of high school football.

GTFOHWTBS!

Luginbill usually is pretty realistic on his evaluations, and I could certainly see anyone placing Treadwell and Williams slightly ahead of Wilson, but for him to act like Treadwell and Williams are light years ahead of Wilson is just totally bogus IMO. And Wilson has significantly more growth potential than either Williams or Treadwell.

[maroonmania]

To be fair, Bear was our top guy last year while Williams was behind Coates and about even with Bray until he got injured.

All that means is that defenses will now get to focus more attention on Williams with Coates gone.

[MSUDawg4Life]

Luginbill usually is pretty realistic on his evaluations, and I could certainly see anyone placing Treadwell and Williams slightly ahead of Wilson, but for him to act like Treadwell and Williams are light years ahead of Wilson is just totally bogus IMO. And Wilson has significantly more growth potential than either Williams or Treadwell.

I agree. That's what I took offense with. To say Bear is "not even in the conversation" with those guys is ludicrous. Of course they are a little more polished than Bear. They've been playing the position much longer. Bear's results speak for themselves. To me, they say he definitely belongs in the same conversation.

[FISHDAWG]

Sammie Coates stats:

34 catches 741 yards 4 touchdowns

Quin Bray's stats:

39 catches 471 yards 4 touchdowns

*drops mic*

so it appears that Bear Wilson = Sammy Coats + Duke Williams for 9td's (C + W ) = B