Good stuff Prediction Pain.
I went to a High School that has produced some well known kickers historically - guys who never missed in high school, had the leg for 45+, got full rides to D1 schools, and played for and won national titles. I would put any of them in a game winning situation without question. All are fairly well thought of in their college careers. When I went and pulled their %, I was shocked:

Rex Robinson (UGA, 1977-1980) 66.7%
Scott Sisson (GT, 1989-1992) 68.2%
Tim Montz (OM, 93'-'96) 64.8%
Hap Hines (UGA, '96-'99) 70%

Your memory really can play tricks on you sometimes about kicking games. If those guys missed the chip, but hit the game winner, they live in infamy!