-
Originally Posted by
Liverpooldawg
So which team that they beat are you going to had the title too?
There is also this problem haha
-
Personally, I think if you are under investigation for lvl 1 infractions or maybe even lvl 2, the university should not be able to participate in any post season until matter is completely resolved. That would put a fire under the ass of these universities.
-
Originally Posted by
maroonmania
That's an NCAA problem. If a school has a win, any win vacated, the opposing team should get credit for the win in a forfeit. If it changes who won a league or national championship, so be it. To do it the way they currently do is stupid.
While it's not necessarily right to award a win to a team that got beat by cheaters, it should absolutely wipe the loss off the books. I cannot understand why the victims must continue to suffer the consequences.
If it's a CG, I could get on board with a team being awarded the championship in the same way the Olympics award medals after someone is caught cheating. Would't call it a win on-the-field vs the cheaters, but would give the other team the recognition as winners-by default/forfeit, and force the cheaters to deliver the trophy to them.
I'd also be all for the NCAA adopting a rule requiring cheaters and their conferences to remove any and an all school-related reference to those championships, including banners, rings, etc.
Last edited by blacklistedbully; 04-04-2017 at 01:05 PM.
-
Originally Posted by
Liverpooldawg
So which team that they beat are you going to had the title too?
Well, in games over a season their game wouldn't count, so that one is more straightforward. In a tournament setting it would have to go to the tournament runner up. Obviously not a perfect solution since I realize other teams lost to them along the way but to me the other team in the finals is the most deserving and its a better solution than having no champion at all.
-
Originally Posted by
maroonmania
Well, in games over a season their game wouldn't count, so that one is more straightforward. In a tournament setting it would have to go to the tournament runner up. Obviously not a perfect solution since I realize other teams lost to them along the way but to me the other team in the finals is the most deserving and its a better solution than having no champion at all.
Why the runnerup? WHy not the team in the semi the year beat? What if the upset a #1 seed in he quarters and it's a #4 They beatbox in the final
-
Senior Member
Originally Posted by
Thick
Personally, I think if you are under investigation for lvl 1 infractions or maybe even lvl 2, the university should not be able to participate in any post season until matter is completely resolved. That would put a fire under the ass of these universities.
I agree. If nothing else, it would keep the notion of providing an atmosphere of compliance at the forefront. But in reality, college basketball recruiting is 10 times more shady, illicit, and rougeish as football recruiting. And the NCAA doesn't seem to give a rats ass what goes on with basketball.
-
Originally Posted by
Liverpooldawg
Why the runnerup? WHy not the team in the semi the year beat? What if the upset a #1 seed in he quarters and it's a #4 They beatbox in the final
A lot of what you wrote there is difficult to even follow. the year beat? Beatbox? But whatever, simply the runner up because they won the most games in the tournament aside from the champion and supposedly faced similar competition along the way. Aside from that there is no solution other than to leave no champion (which makes the tournament useless to begin with) or replay the tournament (which you can't do). So the runner up it is.
-
Since none of you are dealing with facts, which is true for most discussions on this site, here are the facts.
The final NOA does not include football or basketball allegations.
It deals with academic fraud, men's soccer and women's basketball and several professors.
Not Roy Williams or any member of the UNC basketball coaching staff has been accused of any wrong doing after a lengthy investigation.
Those are the facts. Did numerous basketball players benefit from sham courses--yes. But none of that was initiated by any UNC coaching or staff member.
You can hat the coaches, the players, the University, etc but no wins will be vacated and the championships stand. But please go ahead with your comments. This was an academic issue not a benefits issue like UM. These are night and day.
-
Originally Posted by
bobcat91
Since none of you are dealing with facts, which is true for most discussions on this site, here are the facts.
The final NOA does not include football or basketball allegations.
It deals with academic fraud, men's soccer and women's basketball and several professors.
Not Roy Williams or any member of the UNC basketball coaching staff has been accused of any wrong doing after a lengthy investigation.
Those are the facts. Did numerous basketball players benefit from sham courses--yes. But none of that was initiated by any UNC coaching or staff member.
You can hat the coaches, the players, the University, etc but no wins will be vacated and the championships stand. But please go ahead with your comments. This was an academic issue not a benefits issue like UM. These are night and day.
But if academic fraud on behalf of the university enabled basketball players to be eligible, it won't matter if the coaching staff was involved. The NCAA goes after the school, not just the coaches or even the athletic department.
-
Originally Posted by
bobcat91
Since none of you are dealing with facts, which is true for most discussions on this site, here are the facts.
The final NOA does not include football or basketball allegations.
It deals with academic fraud, men's soccer and women's basketball and several professors.
Not Roy Williams or any member of the UNC basketball coaching staff has been accused of any wrong doing after a lengthy investigation.
Those are the facts. Did numerous basketball players benefit from sham courses--yes. But none of that was initiated by any UNC coaching or staff member.
You can hat the coaches, the players, the University, etc but no wins will be vacated and the championships stand. But please go ahead with your comments. This was an academic issue not a benefits issue like UM. These are night and day.
But if academic fraud on behalf of the university enabled basketball players to be eligible, it won't matter if the coaching staff was involved. The NCAA goes after the school, not just the coaches or even the athletic department.
-
Academic Fraud was committed by a university concerning ACT Fraud-- which benefited the students, football team and the athletic department-- what happens, is the students degree null and void?
Are there fake classes also?
What about players graduating with an ISBS degree (that you can do NOTHING with) Is this a REAL DEGREE????....
-
Originally Posted by
maroonmania
A lot of what you wrote there is difficult to even follow. the year beat? Beatbox? But whatever, simply the runner up because they won the most games in the tournament aside from the champion and supposedly faced similar competition along the way. Aside from that there is no solution other than to leave no champion (which makes the tournament useless to begin with) or replay the tournament (which you can't do). So the runner up it is.
For some reason I am having real trouble posting on this board with all my Apple devices. The letters I type take several seconds to appear. I'm bad enough at typing anyway. Combine the delay and autocorrect and it's a nightmare. Is anyone else having this trouble?
Last edited by Liverpooldawg; 04-04-2017 at 05:48 PM.
-
Originally Posted by
Liverpooldawg
For some reason I am having real trouble posting on this board with all my Apple devices. The letters I type take several seconds to appear. I'm bad enough at typing anyway. Combine the delay and autocorrect and it's a nightmare. Is anyone else having this trouble?
Noticed this lately myself.
-
Originally Posted by
Liverpooldawg
For some reason I am having real trouble posting on this board with all my Apple devices. The letters I type take several seconds to appear. I'm bad enough at typing anyway. Combine the delay and autocorrect and it's a nightmare. Is anyone else having this trouble?
No issue with my McBook Pro. Using Safari.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
Disclaimer: Elitedawgs is a privately owned and operated forum that is managed by alumni of Mississippi State University. This website is in no way affiliated with the Mississippi State University, The Southeastern Conference (SEC) or the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). The views and opinions expressed herein are strictly those of the post author and may not reflect the views of other members of this forum or elitedawgs.com. The interactive nature of the elitedawgs.com forums makes it impossible for elitedawgs.com to assume responsibility for any of the content posted at this site. Ideas, thoughts, suggestion, comments, opinions, advice and observations made by participants at elitedawgs.com are not endorsed by elitedawgs.com
Elitedawgs: A Mississippi State Fan Forum, Mississippi State Football, Mississippi State Basketball, Mississippi State Baseball, Mississippi State Athletics. Mississippi State message board.