How Many More Titles Can Bama Win Before The NCAA Makes Rule Changes?

[Dawg61]

Or creat a relegation system for transfers.

At the end of every season, the playoff committee makes a top 15 ranking. Any players from any school can transfer and be immediately eligible, but, if you transfer to a school in the top 15, you have to sit a year, but, if you transfer to a school outside the top 15, you are immediately eligible.

This would ensure that players that transferring would be seeking a better situation for their career than just chasing a ring and propping up a blue blood

You've left the reservation. Life isn't fair and neither is college football.

[ShotgunDawg]

You've left the reservation. Life isn't fair and neither is college football.

Just an idea bud.

Throw enough stuff at the wall and you find something.

Your right, college football isn’t fair, but that doesn’t mean we can’t make it better.

Is it fair to Lashley or Nigel Knott right now that they can’t transfer without wasting a year of eligibility?

I’m Just trying to find some win/win type rules that help both the player and sport.

A draft isn’t a win/win. It doesn’t benefit the player.

Working with transfer rules so that players who could start elsewhere aren’t punished for transferring seems like a worthy cause.

[Bdawg]

Just an idea bud.

Throw enough stuff at the wall and you find something.

Your right, college football isn’t fair, but that doesn’t mean we can’t make it better.

Is it fair to Lashley or Nigel Knott right now that they can’t transfer without wasting a year of eligibility?

I’m Just trying to find some win/win type rules that help both the player and sport.

A draft isn’t a win/win. It doesn’t benefit the player.

Working with transfer rules so that players who could start elsewhere aren’t punished for transferring seems like a worthy cause.

Thoughts on Lashley and Knott: 1) they should have thought about playing time before signing with Bama (if it was important to them) 2) we should have done a better job recruiting them 3) I hope our staff uses examples like this during recruiting to show kids what might happen if they go there.
This post isn’t a knock on your hypothetical rule changes. Just things I thought of when I saw their names