-
Originally Posted by
Coach34
who said he is great? He's a good college QB
Hurts would be #3 on our depth chart. Fitz and Key are better. Give Fitz Bama's talent and he wins Heisman.
-
Originally Posted by
RougeDawg
Hurts would be #3 on our depth chart. Fitz and Key are better. Give Fitz Bama's talent and he wins Heisman.
you mf'ers are insane. Hurts is every bit as good as Fitz right now. Hell, Mullen lost out on Hurts to Bama.
Only State fans would say a guy that is 25-2 as a starting QB couldnt play for us. Wow
Walk like the King or walk like you don't care who the King is
-
Originally Posted by
Coach34
you mf'ers are insane. Hurts is every bit as good as Fitz right now. Hell, Mullen lost out on Hurts to Bama.
Only State fans would say a guy that is 25-2 as a starting QB couldnt play for us. Wow
Relf would probably be 22-5 as a Bama QB. You give Fitz future NFLer's all around him on offense and an NFL defense that has your back and he may not lose a game in the last two years. Hell if we had Bama's receivers, Fitz's completion percentage would jump 10-15% minimum. Add in those RB's and OLine and Fitz racks up hardware.
-
Originally Posted by
RougeDawg
Relf would probably be 22-5 as a Bama QB. You give Fitz future NFLer's all around him on offense and an NFL defense that has your back and he may not lose a game in the last two years. Hell if we had Bama's receivers, Fitz's completion percentage would jump 10-15% minimum. Add in those RB's and OLine and Fitz racks up hardware.
Hurts threw 17 TD's to ONE interception this year. Fitz couldnt do that in 7 on 7- much less vs the SEC. I like Fitz and he will probably get drafted. But Jalen Hurts is every bit as good as he is if not better.
Walk like the King or walk like you don't care who the King is
-
Originally Posted by
Coach34
Hurts threw 17 TD's to ONE interception this year. Fitz couldnt do that in 7 on 7- much less vs the SEC. I like Fitz and he will probably get drafted. But Jalen Hurts is every bit as good as he is if not better.
If Bama has Fitz Tua never gets in the game tonight
-
Originally Posted by
Coach34
you mf'ers are insane. Hurts is every bit as good as Fitz right now. Hell, Mullen lost out on Hurts to Bama.
Only State fans would say a guy that is 25-2 as a starting QB couldnt play for us. Wow
Agree. I do think Key is better than Hurts and Tau though.
Bigger with more accuracy and natural arm stroke than both.
-
Originally Posted by
ShotgunDawg
Agree. I do think Key is better than Hurts and Tau though.
cmon mane- I love Key too but he threw for 125 yards against a Peter Sirmon D on 11/20. He is not as good as either Bama QB TODAY
Walk like the King or walk like you don't care who the King is
-
Originally Posted by
Coach34
cmon mane- I love Key too but he threw for 125 yards against a Peter Sirmon D on 11/20. He is not as good as either Bama QB TODAY
Coach, I heavily respect your
Opinion but Key’s issue vs Louisville was his WRs, not him.
I am convicted that Key is a more natural passer and QB prospect than Tau
I’ll bet you $100 bucks today that Key is drafted higher. Tau is a more athletic Kellen Moore and pushes the football. Once SEC’s do work on him, things will get tougher
Both Hurts and Tau are better than Fitz, but Key is more talented than both ceiling wise.
Want to bet?
-
Originally Posted by
ShotgunDawg
Coach, I heavily respect your
Opinion but Key’s issue vs Louisville was his WRs, not him.
I am convicted that Key is a more natural passer and QB prospect than Tau
I’ll bet you $100 bucks today that Key is drafted higher.
Both Hurts and Tau are better than Fitz, but Key is more talented than both ceiling wise.
Want to bet?
Key doesnt step in tonight and do what Tua did. Key had his shot in the Egg Bowl and turned the ball over a couple of times and lost- against an OM D. Tua did for the NC against a good Georgia D. Sure- I'll take your $100
Walk like the King or walk like you don't care who the King is
-
Originally Posted by
Coach34
Key doesnt step in tonight and do what Tua did. Key had his shot in the Egg Bowl and turned the ball over a couple of times and lost- against an OM D. Tua did for the NC against a good Georgia D. Sure- I'll take your $100
KO
-
Originally Posted by
Coach34
Key doesnt step in tonight and do what Tua did. Key had his shot in the Egg Bowl and turned the ball over a couple of times and lost- against an OM D. Tua did for the NC against a good Georgia D. Sure- I'll take your $100
I disagree. I think Key does every bit of what Tau did tonight.
I think Bama was prepared to play Tau, while I don't think Mullen was prepared to play Key. That alone is the difference IMO.
Key is bigger, steps up into the pocket better, & has a more natural arm stroke than Tau.
You're on. $100 bet that Key gets drafted higher than Tau as a QB. If I'm wrong, I'll gladly eat crow.
-
Originally Posted by
ShotgunDawg
Coach, I heavily respect your
Opinion but Key’s issue vs Louisville was his WRs, not him.
I am convicted that Key is a more natural passer and QB prospect than Tau
I’ll bet you $100 bucks today that Key is drafted higher. Tau is a more athletic Kellen Moore and pushes the football. Once SEC’s do work on him, things will get tougher
Both Hurts and Tau are better than Fitz, but Key is more talented than both ceiling wise.
Want to bet?
Have you lost your ever loving mind? Did you watch the same NC game that I did?
Tau throws as pretty of a pass that you'll ever see. Did you see what he just did on the biggest stage versus what Key did in the Egg Bowl? I'm not down on Key, but you're WAAAYYY off on this one!
You'd squelch on the bet if Coach took you up on it anyway, so it's all a mute point.
-
Originally Posted by
Gutter Cobreh
Have you lost your ever loving mind? Did you watch the same NC game that I did?
Tau throws as pretty of a pass that you'll ever see. Did you see what he just did on the biggest stage versus what Key did in the Egg Bowl? I'm not down on Key, but you're WAAAYYY off on this one!
You'd squelch on the bet if Coach took you up on it anyway, so it's all a mute point.
Tau pushes the football. He in absolutely no way throws the ball like an NFL QB.
His 2nd TD pass was thrown to another guy & Ridley cut in front & his last one was to a wide open guy.
Key is more talented at the ingredients that make NFL QBs successful.
Do you want to bet as well?
-
Originally Posted by
Gutter Cobreh
Did you see what he just did on the biggest stage versus what Key did in the Egg Bowl? I
To add, this has nothing to do with who is more talented & who is the better draft prospect. It's just an insignificant point that confuses evaluators.
Yes, Tau is currently more advanced. My guess is that he received more coaching, camps, etc than Key did at a young age, but Key has better ingredients to be an NFL QB.
If you don't believe me, just wait and see.
Also, please call me out when I'm wrong. If I'm wrong, I want the entire world to know.
-
Originally Posted by
Coach34
cmon mane- I love Key too but he threw for 125 yards against a Peter Sirmon D on 11/20. He is not as good as either Bama QB TODAY
And he was throwing to our smurfs who aren't even in the same league as the WR's that Alabama has.
-
Originally Posted by
ShotgunDawg
Agree. I do think Key is better than Hurts and Tau though.
Bigger with more accuracy and natural arm stroke than both.
This might be the craziest thing I've ever seen on this board.
-
Originally Posted by
Bubb Rubb
This might be the craziest thing I've ever seen on this board.
We’ll see. I’m sticking to my instincts on this.
-
Originally Posted by
Coach34
Only State fans would say a guy that is 25-2 as a starting QB couldnt play for us. Wow
Sure he can play for us. In the 4th quarter after Key has the game well in hand. Fitz will be gone by the time Hurts is eligible. I like Key better than Hurts two years from now.
-
Originally Posted by
Coach34
you mf'ers are insane. Hurts is every bit as good as Fitz right now. Hell, Mullen lost out on Hurts to Bama.
Only State fans would say a guy that is 25-2 as a starting QB couldnt play for us. Wow
WHO THE HELL CARES??? HE AINT COMING HERE!!!!
-
Originally Posted by
Coach34
you mf'ers are insane. Hurts is every bit as good as Fitz right now. Hell, Mullen lost out on Hurts to Bama.
Only State fans would say a guy that is 25-2 as a starting QB couldnt play for us. Wow
What is insane is comparing Hurt's supporting cast at Bama to Fitz's at State the past two years. Come on, man.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
Disclaimer: Elitedawgs is a privately owned and operated forum that is managed by alumni of Mississippi State University. This website is in no way affiliated with the Mississippi State University, The Southeastern Conference (SEC) or the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). The views and opinions expressed herein are strictly those of the post author and may not reflect the views of other members of this forum or elitedawgs.com. The interactive nature of the elitedawgs.com forums makes it impossible for elitedawgs.com to assume responsibility for any of the content posted at this site. Ideas, thoughts, suggestion, comments, opinions, advice and observations made by participants at elitedawgs.com are not endorsed by elitedawgs.com
Elitedawgs: A Mississippi State Fan Forum, Mississippi State Football, Mississippi State Basketball, Mississippi State Baseball, Mississippi State Athletics. Mississippi State message board.