-
4th and two
Say what you want, but dumb move, cost his team a chance. Now for folks saying "well if he makes it", they didn't. Our defense played well not great but Fat Boy should have punted as our offense played poorly and we were making mistakes keeping the Hogs in the game.
Also saying he or the Hogs had nothing to lose is wrong, they were playing for a chance to get 6 wins and a bowl. They had a better chance IF the game would have gone in overtime. There defense today was better than there offense today. He should be fired tonight for a costly dumb play but I'm so glad he did!
Very proud we pulled it off, again defense was ok, special teams hurt us today. This game makes me think we are or we have turned the corner.
No excuse but both teams will be fired up in the Egg Bowl. We are much better playing at home.
HailState!
-
Incredibly dumb move by BB
-
I think our defense played amazing all things considered
-
Just a man trying to save his job.
Punting probably gets you beat as well since we were the better team.
In normal situations, I think you punt, but in Brett's situation, I can't blame him
-
Originally Posted by
chef dixon
I think our defense played amazing all things considered
Any time you hold your opponent to low yards and get four sacks you had a good day.
-
Originally Posted by
chef dixon
I think our defense played amazing all things considered
I agree, special teams wasn't great today either.
-
Originally Posted by
ShotgunDawg
Just a man trying to save his job.
Punting probably gets you beat as well since we were the better team.
In normal situations, I think you punt, but in Brett's situation, I can't blame him
Like I said, it cost him not saved! His chance was us making another mistake by backing us up. Dumb mistake!
-
The way our defense was playing that was a really dumb coaching decision.
-
Originally Posted by
basedog
Say what you want, but dumb move, cost his team a chance. Now for folks saying "well if he makes it", they didn't. Our defense played well not great but Fat Boy should have punted as our offense played poorly and we were making mistakes keeping the Hogs in the game.
Also saying he or the Hogs had nothing to lose is wrong, they were playing for a chance to get 6 wins and a bowl. They had a better chance IF the game would have gone in overtime. There defense today was better than there offense today. He should be fired tonight for a costly dumb play but I'm so glad he did!
Very proud we pulled it off, again defense was ok, special teams hurt us today. This game makes me think we are or we have turned the corner.
No excuse but both teams will be fired up in the Egg Bowl. We are much better playing at home.
HailState!
That was one of the single dumbest decisions I have ever seen on a football field
-
Originally Posted by
ShotgunDawg
Just a man trying to save his job.
Punting probably gets you beat as well since we were the better team.
In normal situations, I think you punt, but in Brett's situation, I can't blame him
This is the answer. I wasn't surprised at all. Second game of the year he definitely punts.
-
Originally Posted by
Liverpooldawg
That was one of the single dumbest decisions I have ever seen on a football field
Agree. We aren't a big play team... Make us have to throw it to win in regulation, don't set us up to play within our strengths.
-
Originally Posted by
ShotgunDawg
Just a man trying to save his job.
Punting probably gets you beat as well since we were the better team.
In normal situations, I think you punt, but in Brett's situation, I can't blame him
Going for it can be justified but not in the manner of throwing a deep ball that has little chance of being completed.
-
Originally Posted by
Liverpooldawg
That was one of the single dumbest decisions I have ever seen on a football field
Ogre's decision (when he was coaching TCUN) to go for it on 4th down instead of punt against us in the 4th Q could be up there with this one. Ogre's decision not only cost him the game (what a comeback from 17-0 down) but cost him his job. I really think there's a great chance that Bert doesn't coach them next week.
-
Originally Posted by
basedog
Say what you want, but dumb move, cost his team a chance. Now for folks saying "well if he makes it", they didn't. Our defense played well not great but Fat Boy should have punted as our offense played poorly and we were making mistakes keeping the Hogs in the game.
Also saying he or the Hogs had nothing to lose is wrong, they were playing for a chance to get 6 wins and a bowl. They had a better chance IF the game would have gone in overtime. There defense today was better than there offense today. He should be fired tonight for a costly dumb play but I'm so glad he did!
Very proud we pulled it off, again defense was ok, special teams hurt us today. This game makes me think we are or we have turned the corner.
No excuse but both teams will be fired up in the Egg Bowl. We are much better playing at home.
HailState!
Our D played great! They scored when the fumbled punt gave them the ball on the 35, they scored when we fumbled in the endzone and they scored when we kicked the football all the way down field and gave the a 1st and goal at the 2 yard line. Take away those three mistakes and they get shutout.
-
Wish we wouldn't have punted against Bama
-
Originally Posted by
Lord McBuckethead
Wish we wouldn't have punted against Bama
It's almost the same thing except we had better field position. I don't blame Bert for going for it. He trusted his team to get it and they didn't. In actuality I thought they deserved the pass interference but the referees were cold and were ready to go home so they kept their hands in their pockets. I would have run the ball off tackle on that play but...
Death penalty or bust!!!***
-
Originally Posted by
Reason2succeed
It's almost the same thing except we had better field position. I don't blame Bert for going for it. He trusted his team to get it and they didn't. In actuality I thought they deserved the pass interference but the referees were cold and were ready to go home so they kept their hands in their pockets. I would have run the ball off tackle on that play but...
Pass interference? Receiver slowed down and got tangled up, it was the correct no flag call.
Trust his team? They didn’t do anything on offense w/o our help. U punt the ball and keep us backed up, u hold us and get the ball back.
Dumb ass decision, it backfired. There is no what ifs when u lose!
-
Originally Posted by
basedog
Pass interference? Receiver slowed down and got tangled up, it was the correct no flag call.
Trust his team? They didn’t do anything on offense w/o our help. U punt the ball and keep us backed up, u hold us and get the ball back.
Dumb ass decision, it backfired. There is no what ifs when u lose!
It looked to me like Durr tripped and fell down. If he touched their receiver it was pretty minimal. Agree good call on the official. Also agree bad call by Bielema. Especially at home. Punt the ball and make MSU drive the field or take your chances in OT. The only small defense I have is the wind may have factored into his decision although if that was the case, I'm not sure why you would have your QB throw it deep?
-
Originally Posted by
Todd4State
It looked to me like Durr tripped and fell down. If he touched their receiver it was pretty minimal. Agree good call on the official. Also agree bad call by Bielema. Especially at home. Punt the ball and make MSU drive the field or take your chances in OT. The only small defense I have is the wind may have factored into his decision although if that was the case, I'm not sure why you would have your QB throw it deep?
I also agree why the deep pass? I’m just glad Fat Boy gambled, he played right into our strength which was defense.
-
Originally Posted by
Reason2succeed
It's almost the same thing except we had better field position. I don't blame Bert for going for it. He trusted his team to get it and they didn't. In actuality I thought they deserved the pass interference but the referees were cold and were ready to go home so they kept their hands in their pockets. I would have run the ball off tackle on that play but...
That was not pass interference. Durr tripped over his own feet. Ark receiver had slowed on his route anyway. Ball was uncatchable
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
Disclaimer: Elitedawgs is a privately owned and operated forum that is managed by alumni of Mississippi State University. This website is in no way affiliated with the Mississippi State University, The Southeastern Conference (SEC) or the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). The views and opinions expressed herein are strictly those of the post author and may not reflect the views of other members of this forum or elitedawgs.com. The interactive nature of the elitedawgs.com forums makes it impossible for elitedawgs.com to assume responsibility for any of the content posted at this site. Ideas, thoughts, suggestion, comments, opinions, advice and observations made by participants at elitedawgs.com are not endorsed by elitedawgs.com
Elitedawgs: A Mississippi State Fan Forum, Mississippi State Football, Mississippi State Basketball, Mississippi State Baseball, Mississippi State Athletics. Mississippi State message board.