Cowherd gets the LBJ argument

[DudyDawg]

Aaaaaaaaaaaaand that game is why I prefer the NBA to college

[smootness]

Aaaaaaaaaaaaand that game is why I prefer the NBA to college

The college game is hurting right now, for multiple reasons. The one and done, while a good idea and a half-step in the right direction, is actually worse than just never having them in school. They need to make it two years or take it away completely.

The officiating has gotten worse and is bogging games down. All the reviews are also awful, they grind the game to a halt and take away the back-and-forth that makes basketball what it is.

And playing your biggest games in football stadiums is bad. It kills the atmosphere and kills the shooting.

[Tbonewannabe]

The college game is hurting right now, for multiple reasons. The one and done, while a good idea and a half-step in the right direction, is actually worse than just never having them in school. They need to make it two years or take it away completely.

The officiating has gotten worse and is bogging games down. All the reviews are also awful, they grind the game to a halt and take away the back-and-forth that makes basketball what it is.

And playing your biggest games in football stadiums is bad. It kills the atmosphere and kills the shooting.

I wish they would go to the baseball format, either go straight out of high school or 3 years in college. There are a few players that can jump straight to the NBA but there are too many going after 1 year now. It is actually hurting the NBA product because of all these 1 and done. The ones who are decent in the NBA probably would have been good straight out of high school. Now you get a lot not making it and going to the D League. 3 years would also help get the college game a consistent name recognition. By the time you know who the best players are in college, they are gone. There isn't any type of watching a player keep getting better over a few years so there are less "stars" coming out of college.

[smootness]

I wish they would go to the baseball format, either go straight out of high school or 3 years in college. There are a few players that can jump straight to the NBA but there are too many going after 1 year now. It is actually hurting the NBA product because of all these 1 and done. The ones who are decent in the NBA probably would have been good straight out of high school. Now you get a lot not making it and going to the D League. 3 years would also help get the college game a consistent name recognition. By the time you know who the best players are in college, they are gone. There isn't any type of watching a player keep getting better over a few years so there are less "stars" coming out of college.

I actually think the one-and-done has clearly helped the NBA, it's just really hurt college basketball. And I know Adam Silver is pushing for it to become a mandatory 2 years because that would help the NBA further. And I think that is the line at which it would become very beneficial to college basketball.

If you push the 'come straight out of HS or 3 years in college,' then I think you're going to see a ton of kids go into the draft out of HS and then if they aren't picked, go the international route. I just don't think enough of the top kids are going to accept going to college for 3 years.

[Tbonewannabe]

I actually think the one-and-done has clearly helped the NBA, it's just really hurt college basketball. And I know Adam Silver is pushing for it to become a mandatory 2 years because that would help the NBA further. And I think that is the line at which it would become very beneficial to college basketball.

If you push the 'come straight out of HS or 3 years in college,' then I think you're going to see a ton of kids go into the draft out of HS and then if they aren't picked, go the international route. I just don't think enough of the top kids are going to accept going to college for 3 years.

You are probably right. Just look at Malik "1 and done" Newman. He would be playing in China right now if he had the chance to go straight out of high school into the draft.

[smootness]

You are probably right. Just look at Malik "1 and done" Newman. He would be playing in China right now if he had the chance to go straight out of high school into the draft.

He'd probably be on an NBA bench after they tried to play him right away and realized he wasn't ready. That's why I think it's helped the NBA. You have that year against the next level up to see if they're really as good as you think, and it helps further weed out the ones who don't belong while giving a year of experience and maturity to the guys who really are top guys.

See Harry Giles this year. He would have been the #1-2 pick and then a huge bust. Now teams get to take somebody like Ball, Fultz, or Jackson who really do look legit.

But if you forced them to either come out of HS or play 3 years in college, I think you'd actually have more leaving straight out of HS than you did before.

[Tbonewannabe]

He'd probably be on an NBA bench after they tried to play him right away and realized he wasn't ready. That's why I think it's helped the NBA. You have that year against the next level up to see if they're really as good as you think, and it helps further weed out the ones who don't belong while giving a year of experience and maturity to the guys who really are top guys.

See Harry Giles this year. He would have been the #1-2 pick and then a huge bust. Now teams get to take somebody like Ball, Fultz, or Jackson who really do look legit.

But if you forced them to either come out of HS or play 3 years in college, I think you'd actually have more leaving straight out of HS than you did before.

That would definitely hurt the college game and the NBA.